Key Facts & Summary
- Women in the Middle Ages were mostly subordinate to men.
- However, some women were able to become important figures and held a certain prestige within the field of medicine and religion.
Overview of Women’s conditions
With the establishment of Christian monasticism, roles within the Church community became available also to women. From the V century onwards, Christian convents allowed women to escape the social obligation represented by marriage and the raising of children, allowing them to educate themselves and become literate whilst performing a religious role.
Abbesses could become important personalities, often governing both male and female monasteries and maintaining private ownership of land. In such a way they had the possibility of acquiring significant power. Figures like Hilda of Whitby (618-80) were able to acquire influence on a national and even international scale.
Spinning was also one of the many female craft traditions.
Until the introduction of beer made with hops, this drink was produced mostly by women. This was a form of work that could easily be carried out even at home. In addition, married women were also generally required to assist their husbands in various farming and craft activities. A large number of marriages were facilitated by the fact that many jobs took place in or in the immediate vicinity of their homes. However, there are also registered examples of women engaged in a business other than that of their husband.
Obstetrics was practised in an informal way, gradually becoming a specialised occupation only in the late Middle Ages. Although women often lost their lives during childbirth, some of them survived and were able to live as long as their husbands.
Life expectancy improved gradually during this period, mainly due to the improvement of nutrition. Just as it was for men, even for women, life in the fields turned out to be very difficult.
Important Female Figures in the Early Middle Ages (1000-1300)
Eleanor of Aquitaine (1122-1204) was one of the richest and most powerful women in Western Europe during the Middle Ages: she was the patron of important literary figures such as the Norman poet Robert Wace, the French writer Benoît de Sainte-Maure and author of the Breton cycle Chrétien de Troyes. Eleonor succeeded her father at the age of 15, thus becoming the most desired and desirable bride of the entire European continent.
Herrad von Landsberg (1125 / 30-95), Hildegard of Bingen (1098-1179) and Héloïse d’Argenteuil, were abbesses and influential authors of this period. The mystical Flemish poetess Hadewijch also became popular during the XII and XIII centuries. Both Ildegarda and Trotula de Ruggiero were writers and experts in medical art during the XII century.
Constance of Altavilla (1154-98), Urraca of Castile (1080-1126), Joanna I of Navarre (1273-1305) and Melisenda of Jerusalem (1105-61), among others, exerted political power.
Powerful Women in the Late Middle Ages (1300-1500)
Virdimura was a Catanese Jew and she is considered an important figure in historical-medical literature. Thanks to the laws of Frederick II, she was able to study medicine in Catania after 1300. Viridimura became the first woman in history to obtain a degree in medicine on 7 November 1376. Her degree is kept in the State Archive of Palermo. Virdimura dedicated herself in particular to taking care of the poor, women and the needy. Her medical licence allowed her to carry out only these tasks. Being Jewish, Viridimura was educated in food discipline and personal care according to the ancient Jewish precepts.
In fact, medicine had a period of exceptional splendour in Sicily before 1942. Yet, an edict of 18 June 1492, proclaimed by the sovereigns of Spain Isabella of Castile and Ferdinand II of Aragon, forced the Jews to be expelled out of the country. French bourgeois women were also educated.
In the Middle East, women like Catherine of Siena (1347-80) and Teresa of Avila (1515-82), played a significant role in the development of theology and discussions within the Church. They were later declared saints and doctors of the Roman Catholic Church. Even the mystic Juliana of Norwich (1342-1416) assumed a prominent role in England.
Isabella of Castile (1451-1504) reigned with her husband Ferdinand II of Aragon following the Unification of Spain. Joan of Arc (1412-31) successfully led the French army on several occasions during the One Hundred Years War. Christine de Pizan (c. 1354-1430) was a well-known late medieval writer: she dealt with women’s issues and is still considered one of the greatest exponents of proto-feminism. Her book entitled The City of the Ladies did not fail to attack the general misogyny of the society of her time; while her work Le trésor de la cité des dames articulated an ideal of feminine virtue for all women on different paths of life, which ranged from the peasant’s wife up to princesses.
Her advice to the princesses also included the recommendation to use their diplomatic skills in order to prevent wars. To summerise, she states that if a neighbour or a foreign prince wants to make war against her husband for whatever reason, or if her husband wishes to make war on someone else, a proper lady will consider this carefully. She will take into account the great evils and the endless cruelties, destruction, massacres and finally the general damage that result from the war. Since the outcome is often terrible, she will ponder whether if she can do something to prevent this war (yet, always preserving her husband’s honour).
Starting from the last century of the Middle Ages, various restrictions began to be put on employment and guilds, with the consequence that occupations became more and more exclusively male. Some of the reasons this happened could be the growing status and political role played by the guilds and the increasing competition carried out by the cottage industries, which led guilds to restrict their entry requirements. Finally, even the rights of female private property began to be increasingly reduced.
According to the Catholic code of canon law, marriage was considered an exclusive concrete link between husband and wife. However, it assigned to a woman’s husband all the power and control in the relationship: husband and wife were partners, and they were the reflection of Adam and Eve. Even though wives had to submit to marital authority, they still managed to maintain certain rights. In fact, both women and men shared sexual and marriage rights, which included: the right to consent to marriage, the right to to marital duties, the right to leave a marriage when suspected of being invalid or when there was a valid reason to challenge the separation, and finally the right to choose one’s place of burial.
Marriages could be carried out in secret by the couple, or they could be organised between families so that the man and woman were, in certain cases, forced to consent. However, in the XII century, in the canonical western law, mutual consent between the couple remained imperative. Marriages confirmed in secrecy were considered problematic in the legal sphere. For example, it was problematic for those who intended to have it annulled by denying that it had ever been consumed.
Peasant women, slaves, and servants, in general, needed the permission and consent of their master to be able to marry; various punishments were in force if such a rule had not been respected. Marriage also allowed the couples’ social network to expand.
The entire medieval society was essentially governed by patriarchy, and women were subjected to male control regardless of their social class.
In fact, the life of a peasant woman was enveloped by prohibition and general limitation imposed by the opposite sex. Women had to submit first to their father or to the male breadwinner of the house. Later, if married, they were subjected to their husband, under whose guidance she remained for the rest of her life. The English peasant women generally could not maintain ownership of the land for a long time. They rarely learned an artisan occupation and even more rarely advanced beyond the position of assistants. They could never eventually become public officials.
Peasant women were subject to numerous restrictions imposed by their feudal lords regarding their behaviour. If a woman turned out to be pregnant without being married or had had sexual relations outside of religious marriage, the lord was entitled to compensation. The control of peasant women involved considerable financial advantages for the lords; this was not motivated by the social status of women since sexual activity was not rigidly regulated, as there were couples who simply cohabitated and did not undergo any formal ceremony. However, this was allowed only if the Lord had given his consent. Even without a feudal lord involved in her life, a woman was still supervised by her father, siblings or other male family members. Women always had very little control over their lives.
Some women who managed to maintain their property rights enjoyed a particular immunity. Moreover, some businesses (such as the production of beer), provided some independence to women workers.
In medieval Western Europe, society and economy were essentially rural. 90% of the European population lived in the countryside or in very small towns. Agriculture played an important role in supporting this type of economy, and due to the lack of mechanical devices, activities were carried out mainly thanks to human work.
Both men and women participated in the medieval labour force and most of the workers were never paid through a salary. In fact, they almost always worked independently on their own land and produced the goods needed for their own consumption. Although peasant women worked as hard as men, they suffered many disadvantages, such as having fewer properties, various professional exclusions, and lower earnings if they ever dealt with other people’s lands.
[1.] Erler, Mary C.; Kowaleski, Maryanne (2003). Gendering the Master Narrative: Women and Power in the Middle Ages. Cornell University Press.
[2.] McDougall, Sara (2013). “Women and Gender in Canon Law”. In Judith Bennett and Ruth Mazo Karras (eds.). Oxford Handbook of Women and Gender in Medieval Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 163–178.
[3.] Middleton, Chris (1981). “Peasants, patriarchy and the feudal mode of production in England: 2 Feudal lords and the subordination of peasant women”. Sociological Review. 29 (1): 137–154.